*** Bug 14943 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

I'm now also seeing this in the erroneous "add" menu created by this bug:
https://bugs-archive.lyrion.org/show_bug.cgi?id=14848

Could someone please have a lot at this, this is really an annoying bug.

Jörg - could you please describe what you're trying to do here? Step by step - I'm not used to using services I'm not allowed to use in Switzerland ;-)

OK, a few use cases (this is all in iPeng, but you'll have the same menus on Controller), you should use iPeng 1.2.1:

Generally, as a first step open the context menu for the current track by holding the cover art on NowPlaying, all use cases begin at this point.

I used 7.5.0 r29618 and test.sn to test these samples but it's similar in 7.4.1 and production MySB

While playing local library:
- On Napster->Album:<whatever it is>->Add Album to Library
- On Rhapsody->Album:...->Album...->Add to library


Last.fm (don't know whether your recent bugfix to https://bugs-archive.lyrion.org/show_bug.cgi?id=14358 will fix this already):
- Love, Ban (the buttons in iPeng's NowPlaying overlay do work, the command's don't).

Slacker:
- Play some station from Slacker->NowPlaying Context Menu->(Rate|ban|ban artist)

Thanks, will investigate.

BTW: is bug 14531 kind of a dupe of this? Or the underlying issue? What if  
you used the contextmenu queries instead of the trackinfo directly?

That's why I asked you to use 1.2.1
1.2.1 should use contextmenu instead of trackinfo.

However, contextmenu then creates a trackinfo menu, so subsequent menu levels are trackinfo. The logs I posed here are not for top level menus.

Don't know whether the bugs are related. I still believe it has something to do with sync/async processing, see the logs above.

[09-12-16 13:17:15.9839] Slim::Web::Cometd::handler (143) Cometd request: [
  {
    channel => "/slim/request",
    data => {
          request  => [
                        "00:04:20:26:00:4d",
                        [
                          "contextmenu",
                          0,
                          100,
                          "menu:track",
                          "playlist_index:0",
                          "context:playlist",
                        ],
                      ],
          response => "/3c112bf3/slim/request",
        },
    id => 80,
  },
]
[09-12-16 13:17:16.2211] Slim::Web::Cometd::handleRequest (835) Request for /3c112bf3/slim/request / 80 is not async
[09-12-16 13:17:16.2229] Slim::Web::Cometd::Manager::deliver_events (214) Sending event on channel /3c112bf3/slim/request to 3c112bf3
[09-12-16 13:17:16.3665] Slim::Web::Cometd::Manager::deliver_events (228) Delivering events to 3c112bf3:
do {
  my $a = [
    {
      channel => "/3c112bf3/slim/request",
      data => {
            base      => {
                           actions => {
                                 add => {
                                       cmd => ["trackinfo", "playlist", "add"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       params => {
                                             menu => "trackinfo",
                                             track_id => 6696,
                                             url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                           },
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "add-hold" => {
                                       cmd => ["trackinfo", "playlist", "insert"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       params => 'fix',
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 go => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], itemsParams => "params", params => 'fix' },
                                 more => {
                                       cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       params => 'fix',
                                       player => 0,
                                       window => { isContextMenu => 1 },
                                     },
                                 play => {
                                       cmd => ["trackinfo", "playlist", "play"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       nextWindow => "nowPlaying",
                                       params => 'fix',
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-0" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:0"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-1" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:1"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-2" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:2"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-3" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:3"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-4" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:4"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-5" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:5"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-6" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:6"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-7" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:7"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-8" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:8"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                                 "set-preset-9" => {
                                       cmd => ["jivefavorites", "set_preset", "key:9"],
                                       itemsParams => "params",
                                       player => 0,
                                     },
                               },
                         },
            count     => 27,
            item_loop => [
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => { cmd => ["playlist", "delete", 0], nextWindow => "parent", player => 0 },
                                   "add-hold" => 'fix',
                                   go => 'fix',
                                   play => 'fix',
                                 },
                             text => "Remove from playlist",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => { cmd => ["playlist", "move", 0, 0], nextWindow => "parent", player => 0 },
                                   "add-hold" => 'fix',
                                   go => 'fix',
                                   play => 'fix',
                                 },
                             text => "Play Next",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => { cmd => ["playlist", "jump", 0], nextWindow => "parent", player => 0 },
                                   "add-hold" => 'fix',
                                   go => 'fix',
                                   play => 'fix',
                                 },
                             text => "Play",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   go => {
                                           cmd => ["jivefavorites", "add"],
                                           params => {
                                                 isContextMenu => 1,
                                                 title => "\$20",
                                                 url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                               },
                                           player => 0,
                                         },
                                 },
                             text => "Save to Favorites",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                          add => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, cmd => "add" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "add-hold" => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, cmd => "insert" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          go => {
                                                cmd => ["albums"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, menu => "track", menu_all => 1 },
                                              },
                                          play => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, cmd => "load" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "play-hold" => {
                                                "" => undef,
                                                cmd => ["contextmenu"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, menu => 1 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                        },
                             text    => "Album Artist: M.I.A.",
                             window  => { menuStyle => "album", text => "M.I.A.", titleStyle => "artists" },
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                          add => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 588, cmd => "add" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "add-hold" => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 588, cmd => "insert" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          go => {
                                                cmd => ["albums"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 588, menu => "track", menu_all => 1 },
                                              },
                                          play => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 588, cmd => "load" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "play-hold" => {
                                                "" => undef,
                                                cmd => ["contextmenu"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 588, menu => 1 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                        },
                             text    => "Composer: M.I.A. & Switch",
                             window  => {
                                          menuStyle => "album",
                                          text => "M.I.A. & Switch",
                                          titleStyle => "artists",
                                        },
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                          add => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, cmd => "add" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "add-hold" => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, cmd => "insert" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          go => {
                                                cmd => ["albums"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, menu => "track", menu_all => 1 },
                                              },
                                          play => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, cmd => "load" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "play-hold" => {
                                                "" => undef,
                                                cmd => ["contextmenu"],
                                                params => { artist_id => 587, menu => 1 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                        },
                             text    => "Track Artist: M.I.A.",
                             window  => { menuStyle => "album", text => "M.I.A.", titleStyle => "artists" },
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                          add => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { album_id => 418, cmd => "add" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "add-hold" => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { album_id => 418, cmd => "insert" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          go => {
                                                cmd => ["tracks"],
                                                params => { album_id => 418, menu => "songinfo", menu_all => 1, "sort" => "tracknum" },
                                              },
                                          play => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { album_id => 418, cmd => "load" },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "play-hold" => {
                                                "" => undef,
                                                cmd => ["contextmenu"],
                                                params => { album_id => 418, menu => 1 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                        },
                             text    => "Album: Kala",
                             window  => { "icon-id" => 6696, text => "Kala", titleStyle => "album" },
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                          add => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { cmd => "add", genre_id => 71 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          go => {
                                                cmd => ["artists"],
                                                params => { genre_id => 71, menu => "album", menu_all => 1 },
                                              },
                                          play => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                params => { cmd => "load", genre_id => 71 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "play-hold" => {
                                                "" => undef,
                                                cmd => ["contextmenu"],
                                                params => { genre_id => 71, menu => 1 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                        },
                             text    => "Genre: Electronica/Dance",
                             window  => { text => "Electronica/Dance", titleStyle => "genres" },
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                          add => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                itemsParams => "params",
                                                params => { cmd => "add", year => 2007 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          "add-hold" => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                itemsParams => "params",
                                                params => { cmd => "insert", year => 2007 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                          go => {
                                                cmd => ["albums"],
                                                itemsParams => "params",
                                                params => { menu => "track", menu_all => 1, year => 2007 },
                                              },
                                          play => {
                                                cmd => ["playlistcontrol"],
                                                itemsParams => "params",
                                                params => { cmd => "load", year => 2007 },
                                                player => 0,
                                              },
                                        },
                             text    => "Year: 2007",
                             window  => { menuStyle => "album", titleStyle => "years" },
                           },
                           {
                             actions => { go => { cmd => ["trackstat", "ratingmenu", 6696], player => 0 } },
                             text => "Rating:Unrated",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => { "do" => { cmd => ["artwork", 6696] } },
                             showBigArtwork => 1,
                             text => "Show Artwork",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  isContextMenu => 1,
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.12",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "More Info",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   go => {
                                           cmd => ["albumcredits", "get"],
                                           params => { album_id => 418, menu => 1 },
                                         },
                                 },
                             text => "Album Credits",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   go => {
                                           cmd => ["albumreview", "get"],
                                           params => { album_id => 418, menu => 1 },
                                         },
                                 },
                             text => "Album Review",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   go => {
                                           cmd => ["biography", "get"],
                                           params => { menu => 1, track_id => 6696 },
                                         },
                                 },
                             text => "Biography",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   go => {
                                           cmd => ["custombrowse", "stdmixjive"],
                                           params => { track_id => 6696 },
                                           player => 0,
                                         },
                                 },
                             text => "Browse by selected",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                          go => {
                                                  cmd => ["findart"],
                                                  params => { album => "Kala", artist => "M.I.A.", menu => 1, track_id => 6696 },
                                                },
                                        },
                             text    => "Find cover art",
                             window  => { menuStyle => "album" },
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   go => {
                                           cmd => ["musicip", "mix"],
                                           params => { menu => 1, track_id => 6696, useContextMenu => 1 },
                                           player => 0,
                                         },
                                 },
                             text => "Create MusicIP Mix",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "On Amazon",
                                                  favorites_type => "link",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/amazon/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420&upc=",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.19",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "link",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "On Amazon",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "Share on Facebook",
                                                  favorites_type => "link",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/facebook/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420&upc=",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.20",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "link",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "Share on Facebook",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "On Flickr",
                                                  favorites_type => "slideshow",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/flickr/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.21",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "slideshow",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "On Flickr",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "On Last.fm Radio",
                                                  favorites_type => "link",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/lastfm/v1/opml/search_artist?q=M.I.A.",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.22",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "link",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "On Last.fm Radio",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "On Napster",
                                                  favorites_type => "link",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/napster/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.23",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "link",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "On Napster",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "On Pandora",
                                                  favorites_type => "link",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/pandora/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&track=%2420",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.24",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "link",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "On Pandora",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "On Rhapsody",
                                                  favorites_type => "link",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/rhapsody/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.25",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "link",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "On Rhapsody",
                           },
                           {
                             actions => {
                                   add => {
                                            cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"],
                                            params => {
                                                  favorites_title => "On Slacker",
                                                  favorites_type => "link",
                                                  favorites_url => "http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/slacker/v1/opml/search?q=M.I.A.",
                                                  item_id => "65e589f7.26",
                                                  menu => "trackinfo",
                                                  track_id => 6696,
                                                  type => "link",
                                                  url => "file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20\$20.mp3",
                                                },
                                          },
                                   go  => { cmd => ["trackinfo", "items"], params => 'fix' },
                                 },
                             addAction => "go",
                             text => "On Slacker",
                           },
                         ],
            offset    => 0,
            title     => "\$20",
            window    => { windowStyle => "text_list" },
          },
      ext => { priority => "" },
      id => 80,
    },
  ];
  $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{"add-hold"}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{more}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{play}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{base}{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[0]{actions}{"add-hold"} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[0]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[0]{actions}{go} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[0]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[0]{actions}{play} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[0]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[1]{actions}{"add-hold"} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[1]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[1]{actions}{go} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[1]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[1]{actions}{play} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[1]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[2]{actions}{"add-hold"} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[2]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[2]{actions}{go} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[2]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[2]{actions}{play} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[2]{actions}{add};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[12]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[12]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[19]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[19]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[20]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[20]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[21]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[21]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[22]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[22]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[23]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[23]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[24]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[24]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[25]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[25]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[26]{actions}{go}{params} = $a->[0]{data}{item_loop}[26]{actions}{add}{params};
  $a;
}
[09-12-16 13:17:16.3720] Slim::Web::Cometd::sendHTTPResponse (669) Sending Cometd chunk:
[{"data":{"base":{"actions":{"set-preset-1":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:1"],"player":"0"},"add-hold":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","menu":"trackinfo"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["trackinfo","playlist","insert"],"player":"0"},"set-preset-0":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:0"],"player":"0"},"add":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","menu":"trackinfo"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["trackinfo","playlist","add"],"player":"0"},"set-preset-8":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:8"],"player":"0"},"play":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","menu":"trackinfo"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["trackinfo","playlist","play"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"nowPlaying"},"set-preset-5":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:5"],"player":"0"},"go":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","menu":"trackinfo"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"set-preset-3":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:3"],"player":"0"},"set-preset-6":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:6"],"player":"0"},"set-preset-7":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:7"],"player":"0"},"set-preset-4":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:4"],"player":"0"},"set-preset-9":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:9"],"player":"0"},"set-preset-2":{"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["jivefavorites","set_preset","key:2"],"player":"0"},"more":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","menu":"trackinfo"},"itemsParams":"params","window":{"isContextMenu":"1"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"],"player":"0"}}},"count":"27","window":{"windowStyle":"text_list"},"item_loop":[{"actions":{"add-hold":{"cmd":["playlist","delete","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"add":{"cmd":["playlist","delete","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"play":{"cmd":["playlist","delete","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"go":{"cmd":["playlist","delete","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"}},"text":"Remove from playlist"},{"actions":{"add-hold":{"cmd":["playlist","move","0","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"add":{"cmd":["playlist","move","0","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"play":{"cmd":["playlist","move","0","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"go":{"cmd":["playlist","move","0","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"}},"text":"Play Next"},{"actions":{"add-hold":{"cmd":["playlist","jump","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"add":{"cmd":["playlist","jump","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"play":{"cmd":["playlist","jump","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"},"go":{"cmd":["playlist","jump","0"],"player":"0","nextWindow":"parent"}},"text":"Play"},{"actions":{"go":{"params":{"isContextMenu":"1","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","title":"$20"},"cmd":["jivefavorites","add"],"player":"0"}},"text":"Save to Favorites"},{"actions":{"add-hold":{"params":{"cmd":"insert","artist_id":"587"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"add":{"params":{"cmd":"add","artist_id":"587"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"play-hold":{"":null,"params":{"artist_id":"587","menu":"1"},"cmd":["contextmenu"],"player":"0"},"play":{"params":{"cmd":"load","artist_id":"587"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"go":{"params":{"menu_all":"1","artist_id":"587","menu":"track"},"cmd":["albums"]}},"window":{"text":"M.I.A.","titleStyle":"artists","menuStyle":"album"},"text":"Album Artist: M.I.A."},{"actions":{"add-hold":{"params":{"cmd":"insert","artist_id":"588"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"add":{"params":{"cmd":"add","artist_id":"588"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"play-hold":{"":null,"params":{"artist_id":"588","menu":"1"},"cmd":["contextmenu"],"player":"0"},"play":{"params":{"cmd":"load","artist_id":"588"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"go":{"params":{"menu_all":"1","artist_id":"588","menu":"track"},"cmd":["albums"]}},"window":{"text":"M.I.A. & Switch","titleStyle":"artists","menuStyle":"album"},"text":"Composer: M.I.A. & Switch"},{"actions":{"add-hold":{"params":{"cmd":"insert","artist_id":"587"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"add":{"params":{"cmd":"add","artist_id":"587"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"play-hold":{"":null,"params":{"artist_id":"587","menu":"1"},"cmd":["contextmenu"],"player":"0"},"play":{"params":{"cmd":"load","artist_id":"587"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"go":{"params":{"menu_all":"1","artist_id":"587","menu":"track"},"cmd":["albums"]}},"window":{"text":"M.I.A.","titleStyle":"artists","menuStyle":"album"},"text":"Track Artist: M.I.A."},{"actions":{"add-hold":{"params":{"album_id":"418","cmd":"insert"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"add":{"params":{"album_id":"418","cmd":"add"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"play-hold":{"":null,"params":{"album_id":"418","menu":"1"},"cmd":["contextmenu"],"player":"0"},"play":{"params":{"album_id":"418","cmd":"load"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"go":{"params":{"sort":"tracknum","menu_all":"1","album_id":"418","menu":"songinfo"},"cmd":["tracks"]}},"window":{"text":"Kala","icon-id":"6696","titleStyle":"album"},"text":"Album: Kala"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"genre_id":"71","cmd":"add"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"play-hold":{"":null,"params":{"genre_id":"71","menu":"1"},"cmd":["contextmenu"],"player":"0"},"play":{"params":{"genre_id":"71","cmd":"load"},"cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"go":{"params":{"genre_id":"71","menu_all":"1","menu":"album"},"cmd":["artists"]}},"window":{"text":"Electronica/Dance","titleStyle":"genres"},"text":"Genre: Electronica/Dance"},{"actions":{"add-hold":{"params":{"cmd":"insert","year":"2007"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"add":{"params":{"cmd":"add","year":"2007"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"play":{"params":{"cmd":"load","year":"2007"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["playlistcontrol"],"player":"0"},"go":{"params":{"menu_all":"1","menu":"track","year":"2007"},"itemsParams":"params","cmd":["albums"]}},"window":{"titleStyle":"years","menuStyle":"album"},"text":"Year: 2007"},{"actions":{"go":{"cmd":["trackstat","ratingmenu","6696"],"player":"0"}},"text":"Rating:Unrated"},{"actions":{"do":{"cmd":["artwork","6696"]}},"text":"Show Artwork","showBigArtwork":"1"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","isContextMenu":"1","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","item_id":"65e589f7.12"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","isContextMenu":"1","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","item_id":"65e589f7.12"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"More Info"},{"actions":{"go":{"params":{"album_id":"418","menu":"1"},"cmd":["albumcredits","get"]}},"text":"Album Credits"},{"actions":{"go":{"params":{"album_id":"418","menu":"1"},"cmd":["albumreview","get"]}},"text":"Album Review"},{"actions":{"go":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","menu":"1"},"cmd":["biography","get"]}},"text":"Biography"},{"actions":{"go":{"params":{"track_id":"6696"},"cmd":["custombrowse","stdmixjive"],"player":"0"}},"text":"Browse by selected"},{"actions":{"go":{"params":{"artist":"M.I.A.","album":"Kala","track_id":"6696","menu":"1"},"cmd":["findart"]}},"window":{"menuStyle":"album"},"text":"Find cover art"},{"actions":{"go":{"params":{"track_id":"6696","menu":"1","useContextMenu":"1"},"cmd":["musicip","mix"],"player":"0"}},"text":"Create MusicIP Mix"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/amazon/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420&upc=","favorites_title":"On Amazon","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.19"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/amazon/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420&upc=","favorites_title":"On Amazon","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.19"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"On Amazon"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/facebook/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420&upc=","favorites_title":"Share on Facebook","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.20"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/facebook/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420&upc=","favorites_title":"Share on Facebook","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.20"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"Share on Facebook"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"slideshow","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/flickr/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.","favorites_title":"On Flickr","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"slideshow","item_id":"65e589f7.21"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"slideshow","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/flickr/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.","favorites_title":"On Flickr","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"slideshow","item_id":"65e589f7.21"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"On Flickr"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/lastfm/v1/opml/search_artist?q=M.I.A.","favorites_title":"On Last.fm Radio","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.22"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/lastfm/v1/opml/search_artist?q=M.I.A.","favorites_title":"On Last.fm Radio","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.22"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"On Last.fm Radio"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/napster/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420","favorites_title":"On Napster","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.23"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/napster/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420","favorites_title":"On Napster","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.23"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"On Napster"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/pandora/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&track=%2420","favorites_title":"On Pandora","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.24"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/pandora/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&track=%2420","favorites_title":"On Pandora","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.24"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"On Pandora"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/rhapsody/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420","favorites_title":"On Rhapsody","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.25"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/rhapsody/v1/opml/context?artist=M.I.A.&album=Kala&track=%2420","favorites_title":"On Rhapsody","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.25"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"On Rhapsody"},{"actions":{"add":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/slacker/v1/opml/search?q=M.I.A.","favorites_title":"On Slacker","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.26"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]},"go":{"params":{"favorites_type":"link","track_id":"6696","favorites_url":"http://www.test.mysqueezebox.com/api/slacker/v1/opml/search?q=M.I.A.","favorites_title":"On Slacker","menu":"trackinfo","url":"file:///mnt/slugpublic/Media/Music/M.I.A/Kala/07%20$20.mp3","type":"link","item_id":"65e589f7.26"},"cmd":["trackinfo","items"]}},"addAction":"go","text":"On Slacker"}],"title":"$20","offset":"0"},"id":"80","channel":"/3c112bf3/slim/request","ext":{"priority":""}}]

Hmm... this is working for me as you describe it.

Playing track -> open context menu by pressing artwork -> on Rhapsody -> Add to library

Now it's in my library.

That's with iPeng 1.2.1.

I do see an empty in between menu though. Is this what you're reporting? I can't reproduce the issue as described in the subject. This works for me.

Oh, one more thing: could you please _attach_ log files instead of pasting them. Bugzilla's wrapping just makes them incredibly hard to read.

Can't confirm on Rhapsody, don't have a Rhapsody account that works with test.sn.
Napster does not work, all the logs in here are for Napster and I wrote that in sentence 1 of the bug, it's just filed against component Rhapsody because there is no Napster component in bugzilla.

Created attachment 6385 [details]
repost of last log

Repost  of the last log.

BTW, the break in the menu that separates one or two items from the rest is iPeng grouping menus into sections of 25 items. Need to fix that, but nothing to do with this bug.

OK, got this to work for the current track, same as here:
https://bugs-archive.lyrion.org/show_bug.cgi?id=14857

Not sure whether you made changes to this but I finally got this working by
preserving some states in my menu structure.

I see the parameters sent by SP have changed (there's now also a 
context:playlist

and 

currentTrack:1

parameter, adding these fixes the issue.

If you've done anything to fix this: thanks! :)


HOWEVER: This still doesn't work for other tracks than the curren one which
probably is not an iPeng related issue since I see that the context menu on the
controller for other tracks in the current playlist is very different and
probably broken (it's a track info menu like for a local track and contains
some nice items - like Album Review - and some broken ones - like Biography and
Browse by selected).

Moving P3 and lower bugs to next release target

So can we mark this one fixed?

Err, not really.

When I filed the bug it was an iPeng issue.

NOW, however, the feature is missing completely, through all interfaces :(
I believe there have to be newer bugs on this, too, at least I got some comments like that from users.

Oh, but now it's ONLY Napster, I believe Rhapsody now works.

I'd say the issue that I reported here is fixed but now there is a new one (probably API related) that has a similar effect...

OK a Napster API change must have caused that. I'll mark this bug fixed.

Jörg - what you're seeing probably is bug 17185.

Joerg, can you confirm the fix?

No, I can't.

Michael's assumption was wrong, this is not the same thing.

THIS is about not being able to add an album to your library.
The bug _I_ filed back then only applied to a single case - adding it from a context menu in iPeng.

_NOW_ as it stands this doesn't work anymore AT ALL.

So no, it's really not fixed, the bug just became ubiquitous.
This may be an issue with the new Napster API but it's definitely not fixed, the way it's now use of Napster is quite severely limited by this as you can't build own libraries anymore on the Squeezebox.

Jörg - can you give a brief description of the issue? I see a lot of logs, and talk around the issue, but no description of the issue itself?

Michael, forget all the logs and stuff, the original issue is no longer around indeed, maybe it makes sense to open a new bug for this.

All the description you need is in my last comment: you can't add albums to your Napster library anymore. That's the bug.

There is a feature in Napster (and Rhapsody, and Spotify, and ...) which is called "MyNapster". It contains your library.

In the past you could add Albums to that library (e.g. after browsing the "Top 100" or searching) through the album's context menu.

That's no longer possible.

BTW, there _still_ is no Napster component in Bugzilla...

> In the past you could add Albums to that library (e.g. after browsing the "Top
> 100" or searching) through the album's context menu.
> 
> That's no longer possible.

Ok, that's bug 16759 - unfortunately they didn't implement this in their API any more.