Bugzilla – Bug 3857
Feature request for Transporter-- Polarity Inversion
Last modified: 2008-02-08 23:48:52 UTC
(reference tmid 7322) Looking at the product descriptions and data sheets for the Slim Devices Transporter and Squeezebox products, I see no polarity inversion capability. Is this correct? If you want recorded music to come to life, and have good imaging and staging, it's a prerequisite that it be played in correct polarity, matching the absolute polarity of the live music, through phase coherent speakers (many speakers, even many very expensive ones, are not even near phase coherent). Having a polarity inversion capability, preferably done in the digital domain, is vitally important to getting it right with lots of recorded music and hi-fi equipment. It's amazing how often the default playback is wrong, even though the equipment is all hooked up "right". With high quality recordings, the effect of inverting polarity on reproduction of recorded music has been astounding to me. The character of voices and instruments often changes significantly. The imaging, staging, focus, and overall presentation can change dramatically. My appreciation of music played in correct polarity is more natural and relaxed, with greater enjoyment and involvement, as compared to listening to the same music played in incorrect polarity. I'm still using a Turtle Beach Audiotron feeding a modified Benchmark Media DAC1. I would really like to have easy polarity control with a Squeezebox or Transporter, along with the other benefits of a more modern audio server. Please, please, PLEASE include a polarity selection capability, per track and per disc in the database, as well as an override polarity control from the remote, in the Slim Devices Squeezebox and Transporter. Your products and your customers are missing a lot without it! From a potential purchaser, but probably not until polarity inversion selection is included.
We aren't going to implement this per-track, but we will offer a server setting. If there were an existing tag for this, we would consider implementing support.
Fixed in transporter fw11
how do you know what polarity your stuff is at and if you should be changing it? just by listening?