Bugzilla – Bug 3254
Common album titles with group multi-disc albums as single doesn't work
Last modified: 2008-09-15 14:38:25 UTC
Using V6.2.2 nightly from 2006-04-07 -I have 3 discs named "Live" by "AC/DC". -The album name "Live" is in the Common Album Titles list. -One album doesn't have the "discnumber" tag and is stored in folder \ACDC - Live\ -The other double-disc album has the first disc stored in \ACDC - Live (disc 1 of 2)\ and has the discnumber tag set to "1/2". The second disc is stored in \ACDC - Live (disc 2 of 2)\ and has the discnumber tag set to "2/2". -The Group Discs option is set to "Treat multi-disc sets as a single album". I would expect to see two albums "Live" by "AC/DC". One with the 1 disc album and the other with the two disc album combined as one. I am seeing three albums (the Group Discs setting is not being used for titles found in the Common Album Titles.
Love that corner case.
Fixed in change 7151
Daniel, I'm trying to reproduce this on our end here; what tag editor are you using? I've looked in both audacity as well as winamp, no sign of 'discnumber'.
I'm using Mp3tag and the tag is TPOS (aka discnumber in Mp3tag).
(In reply to comment #4) > I'm using Mp3tag and the tag is TPOS (aka discnumber in Mp3tag). > I've downloaded and installed MP3tag. When I load up a directory of the music files I've created (or for that matter any file) I'm given the option to edit these tags: title, artist, album, year, track, genre, and comment. I'm still not seeing discnumber. Is this a field you created?
No, this is a tag part of the id2v3/v4 standard. See this file in your setup: C:\Program Files\Mp3tag\help\main_tags.html See here also: http://www.id3.org/id3v2.3.0.html#TPOS In Mp3tag, you can add your own tags to view: View->Customize Columns Click on "New Configuration" button and then enter this info: Name: discnumber Value: %discnumber% Field: %discnumber% and then click on "Ok". This should do it. The data is stored in the TPOS field.
Daniel, Thanks for the ID3 tag education. Looks like we can't quite verify this bug as fixed just yet, something is still not quite right. When 'grouping' as single-album, sure enough they do show up as a single album. However when grouping as multiple albums, they don't show up properly. I've loaded 3 albums, trying to reproduce Daniel's situation as accurately as possible. All 3 albums have the same Album tag 'Live'. One album does NOT have a 'discnumber' (TPOS) tag, one album has '1/2' for discnumber tag, and the final album has '2/2' for discnumber. I'm attaching a zip file containing these 3 created albums, as well as a screenshot which specifically shows the current issue. When grouping as multiple albums, we should see this: Live [the album with null discnumber] Live (disc 1/2) Live (disc 2/2) Instead what we're seeing is: Live Live (disc 2/2) FYI, disc 1/2 is for whatever reason being dumped under Live. SlimServer Version: 6.3.0 - 7987 - Windows XP - EN - cp1252 -Rookie bug tester
Created attachment 1279 [details] zip containing 3 albums and 1 screenshot
Fixed in change 8102
Attempted to verify in latest nightly, issue is still present. Please comment again when there is an available build of slim server for me to verify. SlimServer Version: 6.3.0 - 8099 - Windows XP - EN - cp1252
The change will be in tonight's build, since it was fixed this morning. Alternatively, if you are running svn, update that.
SlimServer Version: 6.3.0 - 8132 - Windows XP - EN - cp1252 Verified as fixed, works beautifully. Thanks Dan.
This bug fix is now part of a released version, and so has been marked closed. If you are still experiencing this problem, please reopen the bug.