Bugzilla – Bug 2335
Cuesheet + flac image stopped working starting 10-16 nightly
Last modified: 2008-09-15 14:37:04 UTC
Music Library - consists of over 550 albums in flac format only. Majority of them comprise of single flac CD image with external cuesheet (Type A). The rest are individual flac file per track (Type B). Last working nightly: 10-14 Problem description: I upgraded to 10-21 from 10-14. In 10-21, (Type A) has stopped working. Error message on SB2 was "Problem: Can't open file for:". (Type B) works normally. In order to trace at which nightly the problem surfaced, I worked backward, installed and tested 10-20, 10-19,... to 10-15. The problem seems to surface starting 10-16. I am now running 10-15, which is working for both Type A and Type B. This is a major fault. Pls correct ASAP. Thanks.
Please try the 10-24 nightly. Thanks.
Tried the 10-24 a moment ago. No. It did not work. Same as before. The "Target Milestone" is set to "6.2.1". How far away is 6.2.1? This bug affect the fundamental operation of the SB2. I think it ought to be fixed quickly.
The issue is that I've been unable to reproduce it. Could you upload a cue sheet you are having issues with? Thanks.
Also - what do you mean by "stopped working" - does the album/track show up in the UI, but you are unable to play it?
The problem started since 10-16 and remained even until the latest nightly. Perhaps a diff between 10-15 and 10-16 could reveal the problem? All albums and tracks were displayed correctly on SB2. When I select an album or a track to play (Type A), the following error message would appear "Problem: Can't open file for:". Same error whether cuesheet is Unicode (UTF-8) or non-unicode. (Type B) is working fine. I am away on a business trip so I do not have access to the cuesheet of my library. I will send you a copy when I return home. Thanks.
BTW. I have over 450 cuesheets in my library. All of them (flac image + external cuesheet) are unable to play. The problem is not limited to just small number of cuesheets.
Please upload a cue sheet you're having issue with! Thanks!
Created attachment 949 [details] Sample cue sheet.
Dan, a sample cue sheet attached. Thanks.
And your flac file in that directory is called 'CDImage.flac' ?
Created attachment 950 [details] Directory structure
Yes. See the attached directory structure and content in JPG.
And is this still broken for you using the 6.2.0 offical release? It's working fine for me here.
I have just installed and tested the 6.2.0 official release a moment ago. Problem remains. The latest working release for me is the 10-15 nightly. Some changes affecting cue sheet must have taken place between 10-15 and 10-16.
Ok. Can you run with --d_parse after setting your music directory to just that single cue + flac?
Created attachment 951 [details] d_parse log (6.5-10-27) bad
Created attachment 953 [details] d_parse log (6.2-10-15) good
Fixed in change 4898.
Wonderful! Which nightly will it appear in? I supposed the fix would be available in both the 6.2.x line and 6.5 branches. Right? Thanks alot.
Yes - both branches, and 10-28-2005 or later.